Currently if the IDF_TARGET env is set, and old sdkconfig exists with
different target value in CONFIG_IDF_TARGET, the set-target action fails
complaining about the IDF_TARGET env and value in sdkconfig being different.
We should ignore IDF_TARGET value from sdkconfig, because we are
actually setting new target and the old sdkconfig is renamed in cmake.
This can be easily reproduced with
---8<---
$ IDF_TARGET=esp32 idf.py set-target esp32
$ IDF_TARGET=esp32s3 idf.py set-target esp32s3
Project sdkconfig '/home/fhrbata/work/hello_world/sdkconfig' was generated
for target 'esp32s3', but environment variable IDF_TARGET is set to 'esp32'.
Run 'idf.py set-target esp32' to generate new sdkconfig file for target esp32.
---8<---
This also adds test for this use case to test_non_default_target.py.
Signed-off-by: Frantisek Hrbata <frantisek.hrbata@espressif.com>
Extend target checks in cmake, in case it's run directly and not via
idf.py or if idf.py misses something. This may happen
for example if cmake variables are set in project's CMakeLists.txt.
Some clean-ups are included along with the new checks and tests.
1. __target_check() function is removed. IIUC it should never fail,
because the selected target is explicitly passed as environmental
variable to kconfgen. Meaning the IDF_TARGET from environment variable may
not be actually used in kconfgen if IDF_TARGET is already set it cmake cache.
Note that the IDF_TARGET environment variable used for kconfgen is not
based on the actual IDF_TARGET environment variable set for idf.py, but
rather on the value set in __target_init() with
set(IDF_TARGET ${env_idf_target} CACHE STRING "IDF Build Target")
My understanding is that the original check was introduced to handle
situation, where IDF_TARGET was already set in cmake's cache and
the IDF_TARGET from environment variable was different. Since
the kconfgen would use the original environment variable(not
explicitly passed as it is now) the IDF_TARGET in cmake and in
sdkconfig could differ. IOW I think the original check was introduced
to cope with the following cmake behaviour
set(VARIABLE "value1" CACHE STRING "test variable")
set(VARIABLE "value2" CACHE STRING "test variable")
message("Variable value: ${VARIABLE}")
output: Variable value: value1
2. I scratched by head how it is possible that the following code
in __target_check()
if(NOT ${IDF_TARGET} STREQUAL ${env_idf_target})
could fail if IDF_TARGET is not set. For example in clean project
IDF_TARGET=esp32 idf.py reconfigure
Here env_idf_target==esp32 and IDF_TARGET is not set, so I would
expect that cmake will fail with error message that the cache
and env target do not match. The thing is that the variable
evaluation is done before the if command, so it actually
sees this
if(NOT STREQUAL esp32)
which is false and the error is not printed. It can be seen
with 'cmake --trace-expand' command. I don't know if this
was used on purpose or it worked just as a coincidence, but
I find it very confusing, so I added explicit check if the
IDF_TARGET is defined before the actual check. Same for
CMAKE_TOOLCHAIN_FILE.
3. Error messages are not formated(line-wrapped) by cmake's markup
so it's easier to check the output in tests.
Signed-off-by: Frantisek Hrbata <frantisek.hrbata@espressif.com>
Extend existing target consistency checks for the two following cases.
1. Target does not match currently used toolchain
$ IDF_TARGET=esp32s2 idf.py reconfigure
$ idf.py -DIDF_TARGET=esp32c3 build
2. Target is ambiguous, because it's specified also as env. var.
IDF_TARGET=esp32s3 idf.py set-target esp32c2
Signed-off-by: Frantisek Hrbata <frantisek.hrbata@espressif.com>
The _guess_or_check_idf_target() function has sdkconfig and sdkconfig.defaults
file names hardcoded. Since config file names may be specified with SDKCONFIG
or SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS cmake vars, directly in CMakeLists.txt or passed in with
the -D cmake option, they are not respected.
Problem is when SDKCONFIG or SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS is set in
CMakeLists.txt. While idf can detect cmake vars passed through it
to cmake via the -D option, detecting SDKCONFIG and SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS
vars settings in CMakeLists.txt would require to parse it. This seems
like error prone approach. Also if the vars defined by the -D option
are passed directly to cmake, not via idf, they will not be visible to idf.
It seems reasonable to move the logic into cmake, where we know the correct
SDKCONFIG and SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS values. So the IDF_TARGET detection/guessing
is moved into targets.cmake, where the IDF_TARGET is actually set. The target
is guessed based on the following precendence.
1) $ENV{IDF_TARGET}
2) IDF_TARGET
3) SDKCONFIG
4) sdkconfig
5) SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS if non-empty or
$ENV{SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS} if non-empty or
sdkconfig.defaults
6) esp32
All config files referred in $ENV{SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS} and SDKCONFIG_DEFAULTS
are searched, compared to the current behaviour. First target found in the
above chain is used.
The original _guess_or_check_idf_target() is renamed to _check_idf_target() and
used for the target consistency checks only.
The get_sdkconfig_filename() helper is now used to get the sdkconfig file
for consistency checks. It looks in SDKCONFIG specified with the -D
option and project_description.json.
With this change config full paths are reported in messages, so it's clear
e.g. from which config the target was guessed from or which config has
consistency problem. test_non_default_target.py was adjusted to this
change and also new test for testing the IDF_TARGET guessing was added.
Signed-off-by: Frantisek Hrbata <frantisek.hrbata@espressif.com>
